Carl Cervone

An experiment with r/dataisbeautiful

November 17, 2026

I’ve always enjoyed making data visualizations. A couple of my favorites from a few years ago were a joyplot of coffee farms by altitude and a series of topographic maps I made in Python.

One of the fun things about building Artio is that I get to do a lot more of this.

Over the past month, we’ve been running a little experiment with r/dataisbeautiful. We wanted to see how good we could get at using agents to research interesting topics, ingest public datasets, and produce data visualizations that people would actually enjoy.

Here’s one we published this morning, showing the date and time of the earliest sunset of the year in every county in the contiguous US. Within five hours, it had nearly 4,000 upvotes and over 500 comments, our most viral post so far.

This year's earliest sunset will be in Maine at 3:46 pm on Dec 10

(Fun fact: the earliest sunset of the year is not on the shortest day of the year. In northern Maine it comes on December 10, eleven days before the solstice.)

The experiment

I’m interested in how we evaluate the quality of outputs from agents, particularly for the less deterministic parts of data science (eg, exploratory analysis, data visualization, storytelling).

A forum like r/dataisbeautiful is an ideal test environment. There’s a large community of people who appreciate good data visualizations, an extensive corpus of historical posts to analyze, and a lot of qualitative feedback in the comments. People are also pretty quick to point out issues with your data or methodology.

Most posts don’t get far. When we pulled two years of the sub’s history, 57% of the 30,936 submissions had been removed by moderators, AutoModerator or Reddit. Of the posts that stayed up, the median got 9 upvotes.

We’ve been using Artio for the entire process:

We’ve also been asking the agents to write down a hypothesis for how each chart will perform before we publish it (eg, “a single striking county map about a shared everyday experience, with a known surprise, reaches 1,000+ upvotes”).

We track the results in our own private dashboard, which updates daily and shows each post’s hypothesis next to how it actually did.

How the agents work

The work is split across a handful of scheduled agents, each with one job:

The human (ie, me) makes the editorial calls. I still pick which post goes up, approve any change to the design system, and do the actual posting on Reddit myself.

The scoring data comes from the Arctic Shift archive of Reddit, which re-captures posts after they’ve had time to settle. We compare each post by its percentile, the share of the sub’s posts from the previous 30 days that it beat. That matters because the sub has gotten more active this year: a 90th-percentile post now needs about 1,150 upvotes.

How we’ve done so far

The results have been pretty encouraging. Of our first ten posts with settled scores:

So far in November 2026, our account ranks fifth out of 551 contributors by total upvotes, putting us in the top 1% of all posters on the forum.

We’ve also had two posts get zero upvotes. Both are in the gallery below.

I’d like to extend this experiment to other types of data science work where we can get independent feedback on the quality of the outputs. In the meantime, we’ll keep making charts. You can follow along on Reddit.

All twelve charts

Newest first. Click a chart to see it full size.

🔥 100+ upvotes · 🔥🔥 1,000+ · 🔥🔥🔥 2,000+ · 💩 didn’t take off

Chart Post
This year's earliest sunset will be in Maine at 3:46 pm on Dec 10 Nov 17
This year’s earliest sunset will be in Maine at 3:46 pm on Dec 10
🔥🔥🔥
3 in 4 deaths of Americans aged 15 to 24 are from accidents, suicide or homicide Nov 16
3 in 4 deaths of Americans aged 15 to 24 are from accidents, suicide or homicide
💩
Top US boys' names from the 1950s–90s are still popular. Most girls' aren't Nov 14
Top US boys’ names from the 1950s–90s are still popular. Most girls’ aren’t
🔥🔥🔥
Six of the seven G7 governments now owe more than a year's GDP Nov 12
Six of the seven G7 governments now owe more than a year’s GDP
🔥
22% of New York-area commuters take an hour or more to get to work Nov 10
22% of New York-area commuters take an hour or more to get to work
🔥🔥
29% of US households are one person living alone, up from 13% in 1960 Nov 9
29% of US households are one person living alone, up from 13% in 1960
🔥🔥🔥
General tech subreddits have grown more negative about AI Nov 7
General tech subreddits have grown more negative about AI
🔥🔥🔥
In 2024, 38% of US ballots were cast on Election Day Nov 5
In 2024, 38% of US ballots were cast on Election Day
🔥
Homeownership rate in the US, by age group Nov 1
Homeownership rate in the US, by age group
🔥
How Americans spend an average day, by age group Oct 29
How Americans spend an average day, by age group
💩
Rent takes 38.6% of the typical Miami renter's income, the most of any big US metro Oct 26
Rent takes 38.6% of the typical Miami renter’s income, the most of any big US metro
🔥
Complaints to the US consumer finance regulator about Equifax, Experian and TransUnion grew 87-fold from 2017 to 2026 Oct 22
Complaints to the US consumer finance regulator about Equifax, Experian and TransUnion grew 87-fold from 2017 to 2026
🔥